Showing posts with label lyme disease legislation. Show all posts
Showing posts with label lyme disease legislation. Show all posts

Friday, April 15, 2011

Loss, Pain, and Frustration


Here is another article that we read all too often. It was authored by
By Victoria Ross, Springfield Connection, Connection
Newspapers, Alexandria, Virginia.


Lyme Disease: Epidemic ‘Largely Ignored’

Governor’s Task Force on Lyme disease hears stories of loss, pain and frustration.

By Victoria Ross
Thursday, March 31, 2011
Bookmark and Share

Tricia Platas, a Springfield mother of four, sat in front of Gov. Bob McDonnell’s Lyme Disease Task Force on Tuesday, March 24, clenched her hands together, and testified about losing her 9-year-old daughter, Amber Marie, to Lyme disease.

“It was a few months after her ninth birthday when we really knew something was wrong,” Platas said. “She woke up one morning in so much pain that she could not walk to the bathroom. This was a little girl who loved to laugh, loved to sing and dance, Amber was the light of our lives.”
Platas cried when she told the panel and 120 attendees how desperate she was to make the many doctors she saw with Amber to take her daughter’s “mysterious” illness seriously. In her frantic search for a cure, she took Amber to a doctor who strapped the little girl to a bed, and waved foul-smelling oils in her face. “Amber was screaming. I just can’t believe anyone would do that,” she said.

“I wanted them to treat my little girl right, so I wouldn’t always ask the right questions, or demand answers. I feel terrible about that,” she said. “You have to push for answers.”

Amber Marie Platas died on April 22, 2002, at Children’s National Medical Center.

Platas was one of 25 area patients and caregivers who testified about their experiences with Lyme disease at Immanuel Bible Church in Springfield. They shared stories of pain, fear and fatigue with the eight-member panel of health department officials and legislators’ representatives. It was the fifth public testimony hearing about the spread of Lyme disease in the Commonwealth.

Led by Michael Farris, chancellor of Patrick Henry College in Purcellville, the task force will propose recommendations to the governor after its final hearing April 25. Farris’ wife and seven of his 10 children have been diagnosed with Lyme disease. The task force is comprised of physicians, wildlife officials, veterinarians and other experts.

According to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC), 900 new cases of Lyme disease were reported in Virginia in 2009, a number the CDC acknowledges could be ten times higher due to under-reporting and inaccurate diagnostic tests. In Fairfax County, 250 cases were reported last year, according to the Fairfax County Health Department.

A deer tick takes about 36 hours to transmit Lyme disease, according to the CDC. The longer the disease goes undiagnosed and untreated, the greater the chances are for brain, heart and joint problems.

“We’re here tonight to listen to people’s stories, hear their recommendations and advocate for more public awareness and education,” Farris said.

A well-known constitutional lawyer, Farris is the founder of the Home School Legal Defense Association (HSDLA) and Patrick Henry College, a Christian liberal arts college that is aimed at home-schooled students.

“Lyme disease is dramatically misdiagnosed, and there is too much denial by doctors that chronic Lyme does not exist,” Farris said.

Mikey Pedersen, a 14-year-old Vienna resident, told the panel that his case of Lyme disease went undiagnosed for a year despite seven doctor visits. He said doctors attributed his symptoms to growing pains. The delayed diagnosis allowed Lyme and co-infections to spread throughout his body causing rashes, severe joint pain, and fatigue.

Kristina Sheridan, a Vienna mother of a teenage daughter with Lyme disease, told the panel her family spent four years seeing 30 doctors, visiting seven hospitals and receiving more than 15 diagnoses before they found a team of doctors determined to get her daughter well.

She gave the panel a list of specific recommendations for the panel to consider, including spraying the edges of school fields and soccer fields with Permethrin, an insect repellant, to kill ticks as well as West Nile Virus.

"I've no doubt both my kids got bitten by ticks on soccer fields,” she said. Sheridan also said parents of children diagnosed with Lyme need to understand the process for Special Education Certification for “other health issues.”

“This certification provides families and the school with the flexibility needed to handle the waxing and waning symptoms, the additional days of absence,” Sheridan said.
Sarah Beasley, a 29-year-old Fairfax woman, told the panel that she is living proof chronic Lyme exists. In 2000, she was a senior at James Madison University and participated in Army ROTC for fun. But then she started having serious muscle and joint pains.

“As soon as each day was done, I’d limp to my apartment and crash into bed,” she said. “My whole life, I had been a six-hours-kind-of-sleep-girl. Suddenly, I would sleep for 13 hours and wake up feeling like I had been hit by a Mac truck.” After 10 years and more than 10 different doctors, Beasley, the director of a local education association, said she is on the path to wellness.

At the end of her testimony, she dumped out a large bag of medications, herbs, supplements and vitamins. “Please understand that it takes all of these to keep me going in the way that I need to function,” she said. “Without them, I will be that girl that is confined again to the downstairs couch.” She added that she wants the panel to encourage research and protect doctors who actually understand “this spreading, debilitating disease.”

Marjorie Veiga, a Lyme disease patient consultant and mother of a teen daughter diagnosed with Lyme disease, said the biggest myth about Lyme disease is that it is easily diagnosed and treated.

“It is difficult to diagnose due to the unreliable screening tests and due to the migrating and remitting symptoms,” she said. “Also, ticks can carry multiple pathogens. If these are not diagnosed and treated, the patient may continue to be unresponsive to multiple therapies.”

“These heartrending cases of misdiagnosis, financial ruin, and social isolation are difficult to hear as we travel throughout Virginia,” Farris said. “But it is important to gather first-hand testimonies about the personal impact of long-term illness. One of our most important goals is to allow people to be heard.”

The final Task Force hearing on the educational needs in Lyme and tick-borne disease will be Monday, April 25, at 1 p.m. in Fairfax. The location of the meeting has not been announced.

“I was so moved by all the stories given at the meeting that night,” Platas said in an interview after the three-hour hearing. “It saddens me to see how many people are still being made sick by this horrible little bug.

Supervisor Pat Herrity (R-Springfield) attended the hearing, and has listed Lyme Disease Awareness as one of his priorities.

In 2009, Herrity, along with Supervisor Michael Frey (R-Sully), conducted a town hall symposium on Lyme disease at Centreville High School. He said he became concerned about the prevalence of the disease after hearing from many of his constituents afflicted with the disease.

“We have an epidemic that we’re largely ignoring,” he said, adding that he hopes the panel considers that one of their recommendations should be to pass legislation similar to that enacted in Connecticut, where doctors are allowed to prescribe extended doses of antibiotics without fear of malpractice lawsuits.

According to “The Connecticut Post,” passage of the bill in May 2009, which allows physicians to diagnose chronic Lyme disease, and treat it with long-term antibiotics was one of the “cornerstone moments of Lyme disease politics over the last decade.”

Similar bills have been introduced in Rhode Island Pennsylvania, Massachusetts, New York and Maryland that would compel insurance companies to pay for antibiotic treatment for chronic Lyme disease CLD.

“For Swine Flu, we went on full red-alert, but more people are afflicted with Lyme disease, and it’s time we take it seriously,” Herrity said.

Those who did not attend the hearings, but want to share how they’ve been affected by the disease may e-mail Farris at lyme@phc.edu.

Tuesday, May 4, 2010

ISDA has again showed extreme ignorance!

Hello friends,

I have to again report that the ISDA leadership has shown extreme ignorance in regard to the long term treatment of Lyme patients with antibiotics. I reference to you the Under Our Skin Blog at http://underourskin.com/blog/?p=738 concerning this matter. Jordan Smith, the park ranger featured in the film has written the ISDA a letter announcing his displeasure with the stance taken by this group again. This group continues to prove it is biased against current testimonies of Lyme patients. I have copied the text of Jordan's letter for you to read below:


Begin Quote


To the Infectious Diseases Society of America:

Almost twelve years ago, I was bitten by a tick at work, and contracted Lyme Disease and Babesiosis. Because of the job you’ve done at diminishing the perception of danger about tick-borne disease and pressuring doctors who treat it aggressively out of business, it took a year and a half and a nationwide search to find a doctor who would treat me.

By then I was dreadfully ill, and as a result I lost my job and my 21-year career. In my first year of antibiotic treatment I got worse. I pursued aggressive treatment for another six years, during which time I got steadily, if slowly better. During this time one of my two doctors was forced out of practice as a result of your work. Thanks to my heroic physicians, I am recovered after a nine-year battle with tick-borne disease. And I am now contributing to society, working, and raising my kids.

Your ineffectiveness and the extent of your compromise with the insurance and HMO businesses are noted. You and your work will be forgotten eventually, as we have forgotten the names of the opponents of Copernicus. Shame on you for the suffering you are causing on the way to your eventual obscurity as prideful scientists who called it tragically wrong. The monument to your life’s work is an unchecked epidemic.

—Jordan Fisher Smith, recovered victim of tick-borne disease

End Quote


Join Jordan and write your letter to the ISDA

Be well,

Richard

Wednesday, February 24, 2010

Flawed Lyme disease Guidelines

Hello my friends,
Below is a great article from Eugene(Oregon) Weekly(http://eugeneweekly.com/2010/02/18/views3.html) written by Phyliss Mervine. I hope you will take time and read it. I am sure most of you will agree with it and can add your testimony to the problems of having Lyme disease treated. It is about time, people have recognized that the existing guidelines to be done away with and new ones instituted.

Be well,

Richard



Flawed Guidelines
Lyme disease treatment options limited by conflicts and questionable science
By Phyllis Mervine

In her Viewpoint Jan. 28, Dr. Sarah Henderson aligns herself with the flawed Lyme disease guidelines of the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA). The IDSA treatment guidelines are highly restrictive, ineffective, and leave seriously ill patients without effective treatment options. The IDSA guidelines panel which developed the guidelines had serious and significant commercial conflicts of interest with vaccine manufacturers, Lyme diagnostic kit distributors, and insurance companies. The panel did not consider the interests of patients and their treating physicians, with the result that it placed commercial interests above quality of patient care.

The conflicts were so egregious that Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal launched an antitrust investigation into the IDSA guideline development process. In May 2008, the AG announced a settlement with the IDSA. In a scathing indictment, he concluded that the guidelines process had lacked important safeguards:

• Several of the most powerful panelists held undisclosed financial interests;

• IDSA failed to follow its own procedures for appointing the panel chair and members;

• The panel refused to accept or meaningfully consider information regarding the existence of chronic Lyme disease and blocked appointment of scientists and physicians with divergent views on chronic Lyme.

Under pressure of the investigation, the IDSA entered into an antitrust settlement agreement with the AG. The settlement agreement forced the IDSA to reconstitute a new panel free of conflicts of interest to re-evaluate its guidelines in a public hearing held on July 30, 2009. The panel is expected to make a decision soon. The settlement requires the panel to consider scientific research the prior panel had ignored and to consider divergent viewpoints. The hearing and the scientific evidence submission of the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS) which included approximately 300 pages of analysis and more than 1,300 pages of peer reviewed scientific evidence disputing the IDSA guidelines recommendations can be viewed at HYPERLINK "http://www.ilads.org/"www.ilads.org.

The IDSA guidelines severely restrict clinical judgment and deny patients access to treatment options. Despite the IDSA claims that its guidelines are “voluntary,” medical boards, insurers, hospitals, schools and even child custody agencies regard them as mandatory and IDSA members enforce the guidelines in unprofessional conduct actions against physicians who fail to comply. The IDSA uses the guidelines as a sword to drive its competitors out of business for non-compliance.

The hardship caused to patients by these guidelines is severe. A recent CALDA survey of more than 3,600 people with Lyme disease found that the average patient waited over four years, seeing multiple doctors, before being diagnosed and one third waited more than six years to be properly diagnosed. In addition:

• 90 percent had difficulty or extreme difficulty finding a knowledgeable physician to treat Lyme disease. About 51 percent had traveled more than 100 miles to obtain treatment, and 53 percent had been forced to travel out of state to obtain care.

• 54 percent had been treated and failed treatment under IDSA protocols. A resounding 81 percent stated that they would not consider being treated under IDSA protocols.

• More than 60 percent of respondents who failed to improve under IDSA protocols improved with additional treatment.

• 41 percent of patients were not able to afford the medical care they needed.

• 88 percent had to cut back on work, school and household activities; 50 percent had to either quit work or school due to illness, and another 11 percent went from full-time to part-time work or school.

Denying treatment to patients has huge public health implications. People with under-treated Lyme disease often lose their jobs and insurance. They go from being productive, taxpaying citizens to being bankrupt, disabled consumers of state-provided services, including disability benefits and special accommodations under Section 504 of the ADA. Children lose years of their childhood, missing important developmental milestones. They have terrible quality of life. Suicide is a not infrequent way out, accounting for 50 percent of Lyme deaths.

Several state legislatures have passed legislation protecting physicians who treat people with chronic Lyme disease from prosecution by state medical boards, and in several more states legislation is pending. The legislation will ensure that physicians are allowed clinical discretion to treat — including antibiotic treatment for longer than four weeks if needed — according to their best judgment and evaluation of the individual patient. Patients are entitled to make an informed choice of the treatment they prefer, based on their own personal values and situation, just like patients with cancer or other diseases. Anything less is inhumane.

Dr. Henderson should examine the evidence herself and not accept at face value the interpretation of powerful, self-appointed authorities who have vested interests to protect. As a public health officer, her responsibility is doubly important — human lives are in her hands. Sadly, because of the head-in-the-sand attitude of most Oregon health professionals, Oregonians have to travel to California to obtain care for Lyme disease. Patient advocacy groups she denigrates in her article have done their homework. I’m afraid Dr. Henderson has not.

--

Phyllis Mervine is president of the California Lyme Disease Association (CALDA), “Empowering Patients Through Advocacy, Education & Research,” www.lymedisease.org

Wednesday, February 17, 2010

Efforts to educate the Public about Lyme disease

Hi my friends,

Below is a great article about how one couple's experience with Lyme disease is being used to educate people in their community about Lyme disease. A piece of legislation has been created to promote awareness of Lyme disease. I think you will enjoy this article!

Be well,

Rick


Begin quotation:

By Laura Dolce
ldolce@seacoastonline.com
February 11, 2010 2:00 AM

KENNEBUNK — The number of Lyme disease cases in Maine tells a story of its own: the reported cases in York County jumped 62 percent between 2007 and 2008, with the increase statewide climbing an astounding 645 percent between 2000 and 2007.

Those numbers prompted state Rep. Ed Legg, D-Kennebunk to sponsor LD 1709, a bill created to foster better awareness of the disease that has already garnered bipartisan support.
What is Lyme disease?

• Lyme disease is transmitted by the bite of a tick, and the disease is prevalent across the United States and throughout the world. Ticks know no borders and respect no boundaries. A patient's county of residence does not accurately reflect his or her Lyme disease risk because people travel, pets travel, and ticks travel. This creates a dynamic situation with many opportunities for exposure to Lyme disease for each individual.

• Lyme disease is a clinical diagnosis. The disease is caused by a spiral-shaped bacteria (spirochete) called Borrelia burgdorferi. The Lyme spirochete can cause infection of multiple organs and produce a wide range of symptoms. Case reports in the medical literature document the protean manifestations of Lyme disease, and familiarity with its varied presentations is key to recognizing disseminated disease.

• Fewer than 50 percent of patients with Lyme disease recall a tick bite. In some studies this number is as low as 15 percent in culture-proven infection with the Lyme spirochete.

• Fewer than 50 percent of patients with Lyme disease recall any rash. Although the erythema migrans (EM) or "bull's-eye" rash is considered classic, it is not the most common dermatologic manifestation of early-localized Lyme infection. Atypical forms of this rash are seen far more commonly. It is important to know that the EM rash is pathognomonic of Lyme disease and requires no further verification prior to starting an appropriate course of antibiotic therapy.

Source: The International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society

Tips for preventing tick bites, courtesy of Joanne and Barry Tibbetts:

• Wear light clothing when outdoors, which will make it easier to spot a tick.

• Don't assume a trip to the mailbox is safe - ticks can be found almost anywhere.

• Be vigilant when working with purchased mulch, or when doing other yard work.

• Don't assume since the tick hasn't been attached long that you can't get Lyme. You can.

• Protect yourself with DEET-based sprays and your pets with products such as Frontline.

• Keep your yard well mowed to avoid high grasses where ticks like to hide.

• Educate yourself about Lyme disease and its symptoms.

Video:

But the numbers only tell part of the Lyme disease story. It's the people affected by the disease who bring those numbers to life, one story at a time.

Joanne Tibbetts is one of those people. The Scarborough mother of three daughters and wife to Kennebunk Town Manager Barry Tibbetts first got bitten by a tick 15 years ago when looking at houses in Alfred.

"I had no bulls-eye rash," she said. "I looked on the CDC site and I was told I had nothing to worry about."

As time went by, though, Tibbetts started to experience what she described as migrating arthritis and joint pain. Then, 10 years ago, after the family moved to Scarborough, things began to change.

"I had tremendous back pain," she said.

And worse yet was the fatigue.

"I was sleeping most of the day," she said.

As the mother to three active daughters, Tibbetts tried to find ways to work around the exhaustion. If she had to drive the girls somewhere, she would bring a pillow and a blanket and nap in the car once she got there. But as much as she tried to work around her health problems, it was clear she was struggling.

"Just being out in the garden was a big deal," her husband said. "We would try to walk a third of the way around the house and I would have to almost carry her back."

Tibbetts could barely make it to the end of the driveway without collapsing. For nine months, her husband said, she wasn't strong enough to walk to the end of their street. And the problems weren't only physical.

"I had a lot of difficulty with word retrieval," she said. "Cognitive problems."

Her doctor told her she was pre-menopausal, she said, that these things were natural as a woman got older. But Tibbetts knew better. A 2006 Lyme test showed some evidence of the tick-borne disease, but was still considered negative by Centers for Disease Control and Prevention standards. Still, it was enough to give Tibbetts some idea of what she was battling.

The Tibbetts searched for a Lyme specialist and eventually found one who was a clinical assistant research professor at Yale and a board certified neurologist. It cost them $900 for a two-hour visit and testing. But at the end of the visit, Tibbetts' tests were sent to Stony Brook University in New York and the results gave her the answer she was looking for: Lyme disease.

Today, Tibbetts is back to being able to take hikes and lead an active life, though vestiges of the disease remain. To reach this point, though, the family has spent tens of thousands of dollars of their own money to pay for extended antibiotic therapy, additional testing and homeopathic herbal remedies that Tibbetts has administered by a practitioner here in Maine.

They've educated themselves so thoroughly on the disease that when Barry Tibbetts was bitten by a tick in 2006 and began to exhibit symptoms over the next few years — despite a negative Lyme test — they knew they had to look beyond that initial test for an answer.

Barry Tibbetts had a Western blot test, which measures your body's response to certain antigens in the bloodstream. While the CDC mandates that a patient has to have five out of six particular bands on the test for a diagnosis of Lyme, his doctor saw enough in the results to conclude that he, too, had the disease.

The Tibbetts' story is all too familiar to Kennebunk's Linda Pearson. She, too, had a tick bite 17 years ago on Martha's Vineyard and was vigilant in watching for a bulls-eye rash that never came. Months later she was talking to a woman at a party about the extreme pain in her knees when the woman asked, "Have you ever been checked for Lyme?"

Pearson was, and after a positive test, went on antibiotics for a month. But once she stopped the medicine, her symptoms came back. She would repeat this pattern of treatment followed by a re-emergence of symptoms over the next several years, through a move to Maine and raising her sons. The pain — in her neck, in her legs — was bad, but she said the "brain fog" she experienced was even worse. And worse yet, she saw the same symptoms in her kids.

Today, Pearson said the family is working with an osteopath and taking Chinese herbal remedies and focusing heavily on their nutrition.

"We're doing a lot of immune-building things," she said, adding that while antibiotics fight the bacteria, it often goes dormant, only to strike again a few months later. Building the immune system, she said, gives you one more layer of protection of the disease.

Joanne Tibbetts said she, too, has discovered the same thing. She said everything from probiotics, thyroid medication and hormone therapy can be used to treat Lyme — if it's properly diagnosed.

Between the recurring nature of long-term Lyme and its ability to mimic other illnesses, from Chronic Fatigue Syndrome to fibromyalgia, it can be a hard disease to diagnose and treat.

That's why both Tibbetts have spent time in Augusta recently, speaking out on behalf of Legg's bill. Legg himself said he feels the bill, which will name May as Lyme disease awareness month in Maine and change some local protocols for reporting and detection, will be a good first step in bringing more Lyme awareness to Maine.

"It's a big step forward," he said, "but it doesn't settle the issue of how to treat long-term Lyme."

The scientific community is still divided on that, Barry Tibbetts said, both inside Maine and around the country. But while that debate rages on, the Tibbetts said they at least feel like they're doing their part to educate others that Lyme has come to Maine to stay. It's a lesson they had to learn the hard way.

"This is not the world we lived in 15 years ago," Joanne Tibbetts said. "Don't assume you're safe."

End quotation

Tuesday, February 2, 2010

More Lyme disease controversy

Hello friends,

For those of us who have Lyme disease, the controversy concerning the use of long term antibiotics to treat us is very important. Here is another article that explains these current issues. Thanks to our friends at New Hampshire Public Radio and especially to Elaine Grant!
I hope everyone will get involved in their respective communities to voice their experiences with this issue.

Be well,
Richard

Begin quote:

>

Lyme Disease Controversy Comes to the Capitol

Sunday, December 20, 2009

"Under the Eightball"

Hi friends,
I found an article in the New York Times that I think all of you will find interesting. It concerns a new documentary movie. I hadn't heard about it prior to this article. I hope some of you will watch this movie and comment back to us so we can learn about it.

Be well,
Richard
Begin quote
December 16, 2009
MOVIE REVIEW | 'UNDER THE EIGHTBALL'
On the Nightmare Trail of Lyme Disease
By JEANNETTE CATSOULIS

Defensible anger becomes indefensible incoherence in “Under the Eightball,” a heartfelt documentary that twists an emotional journey into an anti-establishment tirade.

Written and directed by Timothy Grey and Breanne Russell, the film chronicles their 18-month investigation into the diagnosis and treatment of Mr. Grey’s younger sister, Lori Hall-Steele, who died of Lyme disease in Michigan in 2008. As the filmmakers track the history and politics of the disease, test for environmental causes and watch over the patient’s decline, the first half of the film envelops us in a tender, visually compelling cocoon.

Then things fall apart, so fast and so furiously that it’s impossible to know where verifiable science leaves off, and conspiracy theory begins. Propelled by rage and a string of interviews — with doctors, scientists, authors — the film lurches from Project Paperclip (which welcomed German scientists, including bio-warfare specialists, to the United States after World War II) to the Plum Island Animal Disease Center, from contaminated wells to Japanese germ-warfare experiments.

Taking aim against multiple villains — including Dow Chemical and the health and pharmaceutical industries — and appearing to parallel Ms. Steele’s lack of appropriate treatment with the government’s notorious Tuskegee experiments with black men and syphilis, the directors skid off the rails so extravagantly that there is no going back.

Unfolding like two very different films, “Under the Eightball” undergoes a midpoint conversion from fascinating bug hunt to nightmarish lecture. In the end, critical questions may remain unanswered, but Mr. Grey’s grief and frustration are incontestable.

UNDER THE EIGHTBALL

Opens on Wednesday in Manhattan.

Written, directed and edited by Timothy Grey and Breanne Russell; directors of photography, Mr. Grey and D C Hayden; music by Mr. Grey and Gabe Clark; produced by Justin Blake; released by Andalusian Dogs. At the IFC Center, 323 Avenue of the Americas, at Third Street, Greenwich Village. Running time: 2 hours. This film is not rated.
End Quote

Sunday, August 9, 2009

It's Those Deer Ticks Again!!

Hi friends,
I found this article in the Centre View-Southern Edition Newspaper in Centreville, Va. As always I have included the full text so you can see how this community is dealing with ticks and Lyme disease. More and more communities have become involved in teaching and training their citizens about taking precautions when it comes to tick bites. The author Reed S. Albers does a great job in telling the story. I hope you will find it informative and enjoyable to read as I did.

Be well,
Richard




(Begin Article)

Victims Share Stories on Lyme Disease Effects
Panel of experts recommends precautions.

By Reed S. Albers
Friday, August 07, 2009

Mosquito and tick bites are common nuisances for those who enjoy outdoor activities in the summer, but as Manassas resident Becky Pannenton, 52, learned earlier this year, those annoying bug bites can lead to severe health problems.

"I just found out on March 6 this year that I had [Lyme disease]," she said. "I’ve had it for more than 18 years without even knowing. "

Pannenton and other Lyme disease sufferers listened as elected officials, county scientists and representatives of Lyme disease advocacy groups held a town hall meeting on July 22 in the Centreville High School auditorium to educate citizens about the disease.

LYME DISEASE historically hasn’t been a major issue for the Fairfax County area and is most commonly experienced in the northeastern United States. With approximately 400 new cases reported in Fairfax County last two years, panelists agreed it is time to take preventative action.

"One of the steps I’ve taken to raising awareness is scheduling multiple meetings about this issue," said Supervisor Pat Herrity (R-Springfield). "There’s been a doubling of Lyme disease cases in the county. My wife [was bitten by a tick] but we treated it. Not everyone is as lucky."

Another panelist, Fairfax County Health Department Supervisor Jorge Arias, who has a doctorate in entomology, said that in 2008, 13.56 percent of black-legged ticks in the county tested positive for the bacterium that produces Lyme disease compared with 4.48 percent in 2007.

The bacterium that causes Lyme disease, Borrelia burgdorferi, is carried by black- legged ticks, also known as deer ticks, and transferred to humans through a bite contracted while outdoors.

"[Ticks] wait in the grass for someone to pass by and then crawl up their legs," Arias said. "They don’t jump and it’s hard to tell they are on you. They’re very sneaky."

Early symptoms of Lyme disease include headaches, flu-like symptoms and nausea, but in later stages severe psychological, neurological and sensory ailments can develop such as depression, blurred vision and memory loss.

Deer are the most common culprit for bringing ticks into the neighborhood, Arias said. "There are deer everywhere in this area, deer are the ‘Metro’ system for ticks," he said.

Besides offering Lyme disease information, panelists also discussed preventative measures. Vicki Monroe, Fairfax County wildlife biologist, offered tips for combating ticks.

"Keep your grass short and free of leaf litter, and keep playground equipment away from the yard’s edge and trees," she said. "Always wear insect repellent, dress in long clothing when traveling through the woods and stick to the main trails."

Another preventative measure is to check your body daily for ticks. "Whenever you go out, check your body for ticks," Arias said. "You’re either looking for a new freckle, or a new one with legs."

If there is a tick on one’s body, remove by gently pulling it out with tweezers. "There’s old wives tales about using lighters, cigarettes and alcohol [to remove ticks]," Arias said. "They aren’t true. Just use the tweezers."

The local health department or veterinarian can test the tick for Lyme disease for free, panelists said.

EVEN ONE’S FOUR-LEGGED friends are at risk, panelists said. Pets should be equipped with flea collars and have their fur checked regularly for ticks.

For those who do contract Lyme disease, the experience can be painful and frustrating. Lyme disease is a controversial topic as some physicians do not believe that it is the cause of extreme symptoms.

"No other disease has ever caused such a divide in the medical community," said panelist Debbie McCabe, director of pediatric and family wellness at the National Integrated Health Associates in Washington, D.C. "It is the great imitator and can cause multiple symptoms that baffle physicians."

Even the circular bite mark that is left behind by a tick can be misleading. "Some think they have ringworm, but it turns out to be Lyme," McCabe said.

Adding to the confusion is that Lyme disease screening is not accurate. The most common test, the enzyme-linked immunoassay test (ELISA), misses 35 percent of cases in the screening process, McCabe said.

For some, the effects of misdiagnosis can lead to years of unnecessary suffering.

"In the early ‘80s no one knew about [Lyme disease]," said Pannenton, whose 18-year misdiagnosis led to severe medical problems. "It started out with flu-like symptoms and then fatigue, then the headaches and dizziness came in," she said. "I suggested I had Lyme disease to my rheumatologist but he wouldn’t discuss it with me."

Loudoun County resident Sharon Payne, 43, has suffered from chronic Lyme disease since 2005, and has found few treatments that help with her chronic body aches.

"In 2005, I was on an antibiotic treatment [for Lyme disease] that made me lose 35 pounds," she said. "I decided that wasn’t the best treatment for me. I now use cold laser therapy. It’s the same treatment that was used to treat [cyclist] Lance Armstrong [for cancer]."

Lyme disease can be treated, but there isn’t a universal treatment method for those who did not detect the disease in its early stages, McCabe said.

VARIOUS OUTREACH groups also are available for those dealing with chronic Lyme disease.

Panelist Monte Skall, executive director of the National Capital Lyme and Tick-Borne Disease Association in McLean (www.natcapLyme.org), shared Information for those seeking help.

"I’ve had Lyme for 18 years and it gets harder and harder to deal with," she said. "I started this group because there was nothing out there for people with this infection. We now how five chapters in Virginia."

Support for those infected with Lyme disease isn’t just coming from advocacy groups but also on Capitol Hill.

Dan Scandling, chief of staff for U.S. Rep. Frank Wolf (R-10), delivered some hopeful news that lobbying efforts are paying off.

"A $6 million increase for the Centers for Disease Control budget will increase Lyme disease research," he said.

What To Do If Bitten?
Step 1: Don't panic.
Step 2: Gently pull the tick straight out by grabbing the tick as close to the skin as possible with tweezers.
Step 3: Place the tick in a bottle or bag labeled with the patient's name, address and date the tick was removed.
Step 4: Have the tick identified and tested by a lab, health department or veterinarian.
Step 5: Seek immediate treatment if tick tests positive for Lyme disease.
Sources: The National Capital Lyme and Tick-Borne Disease Association, Fairfax County Health Department
(End Article)

©2009 Connection Newspapers. All Rights Reserved. Privacy Policy
1606 King Street ♦ Alexandria, VA 22314 ♦ 703-821-5050

Thursday, May 21, 2009

What We don't know about Lyme.

Hello again,

This is a great article from Pamela Weintraub. It is quite long, but well worth taking the time to read. There is a lot of great information. This last week, I had a couple of appointments with my regular doctors and I was again disheartened at their lack of knowledge of Lyme disease. It was as though they didn't care that I was still suffering from Lyme disease, but that because they didn't know anything about it, it excused them from trying to treat me. They would address my diabetes(brought on by the Lyme disease)but that was all they could do for me. They made the comment that they would let whoever is working with me on Lyme, if anyone, treat me for that. It was infuriating and I resolved again to work harder on being a Lyme disease activist. The work that Pamela Weintraub has done for Lyme disease patients is second to none. For those of you who haven't read any of her books, I encourage to do so.

More resolved than ever,
Richard







What We Don't Know About Lyme

When a mysterious and debilitating illness overtook her and her family, the author struggled to find some answers. What she discovered about Lyme disease - and how little is actually known or agreed upon by the medical experts - is something everyone who goes outdoors should learn.
What We Don't Know About Lyme

By Pamela Weintraub


Features,
June 2009

Lume 101
Slipping Through the Cracks
Lyme on the Brain
The Treatment Controversy
Tick Menagerie
A New Lyme Science
Last Dance With Lyme
How to Protect Yourself Against Lyme Disease
Finding a Provider
Web Resources

After we moved from the city to a wooded property in the suburban hamlet of Chappaqua, N.Y., in 1993, our family began to get sick. At first, the vague headaches, joint pains and bone weariness were so subtle they barely merited note. But as years passed, these symptoms intensified into frank signs of disease.

My arms and legs buzzed so palpably I felt like I was wired to a power grid. A relentless migraine became so intense I spent hours each day in a darkened room, in bed. My husband, Mark, an avid tennis player, began stumbling and bumping into walls. He was an award-winning journalist, but slowly he began struggling with memory and groping for words. Our youngest son, David, began to sleep — first, so long that he could not do his homework or see his friends; eventually, so much (15 or more hours a day) that he could not get to class.

Hardest hit was Jason, our oldest, who suffered fatigue and shooting pains starting at age 9, the year we moved to our little house in the woods. The doctors called these “growing pains” normal, but by February 2000, Jason, then 16, was essentially disabled. An honor student, he now had trouble reading even simple paragraphs. His joints and muscles hurt so much it was difficult for him to walk. And he couldn’t tolerate sound and light. On medical leave from high school, he spent his days in the tub in our darkened main-floor bathroom as hot water and steam eased his pain.

As his condition worsened, and as all sorts of lab tests came back negative, a raft of specialists at New York City’s top teaching hospitals suggested diagnoses ranging from migraine aura (migraine without the pain) to Fifth’s disease (caused by parvovirus). Each diagnosis elicited a treatment, but none of them worked.

“What about Lyme disease?” I asked from time to time, since we lived in an area where the infection was endemic; our backyard was a haven for deer, and Jason spent summers playing in a fort in the woods behind our house.

“There are too many symptoms here, and he’s way too sick for Lyme disease,” replied the pediatrician, who declined to even test for it. But with answers still eluding us, the pediatrician finally drew blood for a Western blot, a diagnostic test that matched antibodies produced by the patient against the proteins of the invading organism — in this case the bacterium known to cause Lyme.

When the labs came back, Jason had so many “bands” — with each band considered an antibody-protein match — that the result was off-the-charts positive. By the summer of that year, the rest of us had been diagnosed as well.

The news was a relief. With a solid diagnosis, we were told by doctors, we could get treated for this easily curable infection, and move on. We felt a flush of optimism, but it turned out that our struggle had just begun. I would spend the next nine years trying to make sense of our misdiagnoses and seeking effective treatment for my children.

Lyme 101 (Back to Top)
What I didn’t know about Lyme disease back then could have filled a book — one that, as a longtime science and medical journalist, I eventually wrote. My book, Cure Unknown: Inside the Lyme Epidemic (St. Martin’s Press, 2008), explores the complex science and disturbing political war over the illness. But a few facts can be served up straight: Lyme disease is caused by the spirochete Borrelia burgdorferi, a spiral-shaped bacterium, and is generally transmitted to people through the bite of a deer tick.

The disease arrived in the Northeast United States, northwest California and the Great Lakes region in force in the 1970s, as the continent was being reforested and new suburban housing was increasingly built adjacent to woods. The spirochete lived in the blood of rodents and other small mammals inhabiting those woods. When ticks bit these mammals they became infected. When those same ticks bit human hosts, they transmitted Lyme disease to them.

Pushing the disease to epidemic proportions, however, required something else: large mammals, like deer, are each able to provide nourishment for hundreds of large adult ticks, enabling them to reproduce en masse. As the deer population exploded across the forested regions of the country, the Lyme epidemic followed suit. Ultimately, infected ticks traversed the continental flyways on the backs of migrating birds, bringing Lyme to every state. Today, 12 to 40 percent of deer ticks are infected in the most endemic areas of the Northeast, and between 3 and 40 percent in endemic areas of the West Coast. With more than 200,000 CDC-acknowledged cases a year in the United States (the tip of the iceberg, many believe), Lyme has become one of country’s fastest-spreading diseases.

Slipping Through the Cracks (Back to Top)
When diagnosed with a Lyme rash and treated early, most infected patients are easily cured. But this upbeat message has little meaning for those diagnosed late. Show up at the doctor without a rash, and diagnosing Lyme disease becomes an elaborate, labyrinthine affair.

The standard guidelines, published by the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA), call for early diagnosis exclusively through the presence of that telltale rash — mistakenly thought of by many practitioners as a classic “bull’s-eye” shape. Yet the spreading red rash with areas of white clearing, called an erythema migrans, might not be round or oval — let alone a bull’s eye. (Jason’s rash, which I later recognized in a medical textbook, was dismissed by our medical group because it covered his torso in a swath.) According to some studies and estimates, fewer than 60 percent of Lyme patients ever exhibit or notice a rash of any sort.

Those without this early sign may roam the diagnostic desert for years seeking answers. Yet, IDSA guidelines require that, to qualify for diagnosis, patients without the rash must present with one of a small group of quantifiable disease signs, from measurable nerve damage to grossly swollen knees. Though many experts say a significant percentage of Lyme patients experience only “symptoms” — headache, memory loss or fatigue — IDSA calls these problems just too vague to consider a diagnosis of Lyme. But, even with objective signs like swollen knees, patients must pass a series of tests before a diagnosis can be made.

And that’s the other part of the problem. Should the patient present those frank signs of disease and qualify for the test, the bar for passing is set perilously high for some. According to the peer-reviewed journal Mayo Clinic Proceedings, “The tests are prone to false-negative and false-positive results and can be misleading, especially early in the course of the disease. . . . Because serologic [blood] testing is not 100 percent sensitive or specific, some people with Lyme disease will not have confirmatory laboratory results.”

The most comprehensive review of the standard Lyme tests comes from Johns Hopkins University. Working with patients from Pennsylvania and Maryland, the Hopkins scientists studied state-of-the-art serology and DNA tests for Lyme and found serious flaws: Most tellingly, when the standard two-step method recommended by the CDC was used on patients with other laboratory evidence of Lyme disease, it was positive between 45 percent and 77 percent of the time. As for DNA tests, the Hopkins researchers reported these rarely pick up otherwise-confirmed Lyme disease at all.

It is made all the more complicated because there are hundreds of strains of the Lyme disease spirochete throughout the world, says Benjamin Luft, MD, chief of the Division of Infectious Diseases at the State University of New York at Stony Brook. Each strain has its own combination of proteins, evoking a variety of bands on diagnostic tests; some will match the pattern the CDC has approved for a positive on the Western blot (the second of two tests in the series), but others may not. Each Lyme strain evokes a unique antibody pattern and its own flavor of disease.

In short, Mayo Clinic researchers note, diagnosis should be clinical — based not on the tests but on the patient and the patient’s situation as a whole. With so many strains of Lyme disease and a unique immune system for each new patient, this only makes sense. Yet with Lyme disease so controversial, most primary-care doctors end up deferring to the tests, leaving those who fail them out in the cold.

“I’ve been scraping Lyme patients off the sidewalk for years,” says Kenneth Liegner, MD, who practices in Armonk, N.Y., not far from where my family got sick. “By the time some of these people get to me, they are so disabled they can barely think or walk.”

Lyme on the Brain (Back to Top)
Given the barriers to diagnosis, many patients slide ever deeper into illness, where disability can be profound. Lyme invades not just our skin and our joints, but our hearts, nervous systems and eyes. Lyme is commonly considered a knee disease, an impediment in tennis, but the Lyme spirochete, like the syphilis spirochete, also invades the brain.

Testing hundreds of such patients, New York University neuropsychologist Leo J. Shea III, PhD, found specific deficits in concentration, short-term memory and processing speed. Patients can be so impaired they have trouble driving around their neighborhoods and can no longer perform their jobs.

Psychiatrist Brian Fallon, MD, director of the Lyme and Tick Borne Diseases Research Center at Columbia University Medical Center, found that brain infection could trigger a host of psychiatric problems, ranging from bipolar disorder and depression to panic and obsessive-compulsive disorder (OCD).

Time and again, Fallon has seen Lyme disease “misdiagnosed as a primary psychiatric problem,” while the root issue — infection with the spirochete B. burgdorferi — was never addressed. This is especially damaging, he says, since a delay in treatment could turn an acute and easily curable infection into a chronic disease highly resistant to treatment.

The Treatment Controversy (Back to Top)
Patients diagnosed in the earliest stage of the disease through a classic rash can usually look forward to full recovery after a monthlong regimen of the oral antibiotics doxycycline or amoxicillin. Those with neurological or arthritic symptoms may be offered intravenous ceftriaxone for a month or two. But experts like Luft and Liegner have found that some 20 percent of those infected for over a year before the start of treatment will fail these protocols and stay sick.

Without further options from the IDSA team, these late-diagnosed patients have sought help from controversial doctors known as Lyme-Literate MDs (LLMDs), who argue that longer courses, higher doses and multidrug antibiotic regimens provide a viable option for many of the “incurable” 20 percent. As ever more patients flock to LLMDs like Liegner, the controversy has mounted, with IDSA pitted against another, newer group: the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society (ILADS). IDSA says the short-term treatment always stamps out infection and argues that overexposure to antibiotics can generate treatment-resistant bugs. Competing guidelines from ILADS hold that patients already have a hard-to-treat infection (chronic, persistent Lyme disease) and that more aggressive treatment is thus warranted.

The debate has recently come closer to resolution with surprising research from veterinary scientist Stephen Barthold, DVM, PhD, who spent 25 years investigating Lyme disease at Yale before setting up shop as director of the Center for Comparative Medicine at the University of California at Davis. Barthold reports that if he allows the infection to remain untreated for months across a range of mammal species in the lab, he can always recover living spirochetes, generally sequestered in tissues that are rich in collagen. When laboratory mice infected with these spirochetes are treated with what should be effective doses of various antibiotics, the spirochetes cannot be cultured from tissues by conventional means, but they are alive and can be transmitted by ticks to other mice.

The finding resonates with what late-diagnosed patients report: If surviving spirochetes are so sluggish they cannot replicate, they may be impervious to antibiotics that work by targeting bacterial cells as they divide. The persisting spirochetes could be the presumptive source of the constitutional symptoms like pain and fatigue that often follow treatment; they may be provoking the production of symptom-causing cytokines (immune molecules), yet still be too low in number to cause the gross inflammation or provoke the antibody response that many mainstream experts call the sine qua non of the disease. Infection might be suppressed but not eradicated by treatment, as so many relapsing patients report.

Spurred by the findings, university-based researchers are attacking the infection on several fronts. Scientists like Luft and Barthold are actively testing antibiotics designed to purge these dormant, resistant spirochetes. Some researchers are trying to destroy them with nanotechnology and heat. And a California company called Viral Genetics, with research headed by M. Karen Newell, PhD, and aided by Nobel laureate Luc Montagnier, discoverer of the HIV virus, is trying to modulate the immune system so it can clean out infection on its own. Still others suggest that the low-level infection might be benign if the immune response could be contained.

Tick Menagerie (Back to Top)
Improved treatments for Lyme disease alone may not solve the problem. There are other infections inhabiting the ticks that spread Lyme, and they are factors as well. The malaria-like parasite Babesia infects our red blood cells and results in fever, exhaustion and drenching sweats. Babesiosis combined with Lyme disease can be especially protracted and difficult to treat. Tick-borne bacteria like Anaplasma and Ehrlichia, which live in human cells, are rife throughout regions where Lyme has reared its head. These organisms don’t necessarily respond to all common treatment for Lyme disease and may cause serious illness even when Lyme is not involved.

Added to this are other microbes as well; though still controversial, these, too, are now considered possible agents of the disease complex broadly referred to as “Lyme.” One of the most notable is the rod-shaped bacterium Bartonella henselae, known as a cause of “cat scratch” disease and commonly transmitted by cats. More recently, forms of bartonella have been discovered in abundance in deer ticks. Some doctors cite Bartonella as a culprit when symptoms are particularly neuropsychiatric, and when treatment for Lyme does not work.

Another tick-borne suspect, Mycoplasma, has been discovered in deer ticks in Connecticut and New Jersey. “This could be the missing link,” says Eva Sapi, PhD, associate professor of biology at the University of New Haven, who also hypothesizes that nematodes play a role in tick-borne disease. It would explain why some patients don’t get well when treated for Lyme disease alone. Other researchers have found Tularemia, often an agent of bio-terrorism, in Lyme ticks.

A host of other spirochetes, some not yet identified, complete the scene. Yale researchers found that 20 percent of the spirochetes thought to be Borrelia burgdorferi in the Northeast are really another species, a relapsing fever spirochete never seen in North America before. There’s a still-unidentified spirochete in Montana, this time transmitted by the wood tick. And then there’s the lonestar tick, which has recently spread from the South throughout the Midwest and up the East Coast, as far north as Maine. The lonestar carries an unidentified spirochete, the cause of a Lymelike disease that the CDC has recently recognized.

“We are just starting to understand the full range of infections that we might get,” says David H. Persing, MD, PhD, chief medical and technology officer for Cepheid, a California biotech firm and a world expert in molecular diagnostics. “I don’t think we know half of the agents that are potentially transmissible by ticks.”

Add to this the morphing quality of the various microbes implicated in these Lymelike diseases. Through constant shifting of plasmid DNA among the microbes, ticks facilitate a rapid form of evolution and drive the creation of novel strains and microbes, virtually nonstop. Indeed, in the universe of emerging infectious disease, the tick is the final frontier. The ultimate germ generator, it is the ideal wet lab for microorganisms to mix and remix in infinite formats, spewing a kaleidoscopic oeuvre of novel bacteria and viruses, some of them pathogens the world has never seen.

A New Lyme Science (Back to Top)
I wish I had understood Lyme as an emerging infectious disease and political hot potato when my family first got sick. Exposed to the noxious debate, the naive patient sees two polarized factions and feels pressured to choose one. But interview the workbench researchers and you will find a complex, nuanced reality emerging from the science itself. Sadly, the vicious political fight over Lyme disease has dumbed down the dialogue and prevented the best science from being heard.

In 2009, the pace of scientific progress is great. Instead of testing for a mere 10 antibodies to a limited number of spirochetal proteins — the procedure still being used in most of today’s commercial labs — new diagnostics that Luft and his Stony Brook colleagues have developed will use proteomics (study of proteins) to tap 1,800 B. burgdorferi proteins found across the range of strains. “We want to test against the entire array of borrelia proteins in all their variability,” says Luft. “So if I look at a patient over time, over the course of their disease I can see whether new proteins, ones we’ve never noticed, might emerge.”

The work on strains could alter how we diagnose and treat the disease in the years to come, says Alan Barbour, director of the Pacific-Southwest Regional Center of Excellence for Biodefense and Emerging Infectious Diseases at the University of California Irvine and one of the world’s foremost spirochete experts. “If some strains are more likely than others to spread in the blood, and by that route to other tissues, then identification of the strain a person is infected with could help guide therapy,” Barbour explains. “Some strains may call for a longer course of antibiotics. The problem is isolating the microbe out of the patient to see what strain it is. This could be done by a Polymerase Chain Reaction (PCR) test of the blood or a skin biopsy, when there is a rash. Isolating the microbe is harder when the illness has been going on for longer than a few weeks, but any isolate of Borrelia burgdorferi from a patient would mean a diagnosis of Lyme disease.”

Also shedding light on treatment is genomics (the study of genes). The Luft team has recently found that Lyme spirochetes have genes for pumping out the first-line antibiotic doxycycline. This means that even as doxycycline enters the Lyme bacterium, it is being ejected, much like a sump pump might eject water from a basement floor. As a result, the dose might not climb high enough to kill the infection, and the patient won’t get well.

Based on this finding, Luft is now studying another drug — tigecycline, an intravenous antibiotic currently used for infections of the abdominal organs and skin. Its mechanism is much like that of doxycycline — except that its chemical structure inhibits the spirochetes’ “pump,” keeping the antibiotic from being ejected by the cells. “It’s a hundred times more active against the spirochete than doxycycline. Instead of just inhibiting the spirochetes, like doxy, it kills them dead,” says Luft.

“We’re at a critical point,” he adds. “We have powerful new tools and a fundamental understanding of the biology of the Borrelia. We know every gene in that organism. We know all the variations of those genes. We know what’s in the human genome. So, when someone gets sick, we’ve got to put this together, in context, and ask what’s going on.”

Indeed, work like this will explain why prognosis varies so widely from one patient to the next. With so many strains, so many co-infections and so many immune systems, Lyme — in the broad sense of the word — will never be one-size-fits-all.

“Some researchers have thrown down their gloves and retreated to their corners, leaving patients out in the cold,” says Luft. “But despite what they say, the patients are still sick. It’s a question of doing right by them — it’s not a question of whether you might have to eat crow. We’ve got to go in and do the right experiments, and then we can look truth in the eye.”

Last Dance With Lyme (Back to Top)
My family has come a long way since our Lyme diagnoses almost a decade ago. We’ve left the Lymelands for safer ground — the concrete expanse of Brooklyn. I’ve been off antibiotics since 2004 and am back at a full-time job. Mark continues to relapse when he stops his antibiotic, but with it, he works his day job, plays tennis and seems fine. Jason has recovered. He graduated from Brown University in spring 2008 and leaves for film school in the fall.

But Lyme still clouds our lives because our younger son, David, was re-infected in Westchester County a couple of years back and remains ill.

In all my years of research, I never doubted that IDSA was right about early Lyme: Treat the rash and a cure would be guaranteed. So in the summer of 2007, when David called to tell me that friends in his college dorm had recognized a classic bull’s-eye rash on his arm, I was actually relieved: For once, we’d caught it early. A month of antibiotics, I told myself, and David would be cured.

We took a 40-minute drive to Dr. Daniel Cameron’s office in downtown Mount Kisco, N.Y., and his physician assistant easily diagnosed a bull’s-eye-shaped erythema migrans that was an archetype of the form. She prescribed a few weeks of amoxicillin and sent us home.

“When you get a rash so classic that everyone at college tells you it’s Lyme disease, it’s a beautiful thing,” Dan Cameron, now president of ILADS, said at the time.

But by spring 2008, David’s fatigue was so profound, his memory and focus so poor, that he had to drop his classes at Vassar College and come home. Back in New York, doctors discovered gross damage to David’s cranial nerves — irrefutable, IDSA-style proof of inflammatory disease and hardcore evidence of Lyme. Ordering more tests, Cameron found not just Lyme disease but a co-infection — babesiosis — known to complicate the picture and make Lyme harder to treat.

I completed work on my book about this mysterious disease more than a year ago, but I know now that our journey is far from over. Our family, along with many others, continues to deal with the fallout at the frontlines of an epidemic, in that unforgiving land called Lyme.

Pamela Weintraub is a senior editor at Discover Magazine and author of Cure Unknown: Inside the Lyme Epidemic (St. Martin’s Press, 2008). She writes a blog on emerging disease for Psychology Today.

How to Protect Yourself Against Lyme Disease (Back to Top)
For those who live and work in Lyme endemic areas, a little protection goes a long way. You can enjoy nature, according to Pat Smith, president of the Lyme Disease Association, as long as you take some precautions:

* Walk in the middle of trails. Avoid sitting on logs or leaning on trees.
* Wear a hat. Tuck your hair in, if possible.

* Wear a long-sleeved shirt, fitted at the waist.
* Wear boots or shoes, not sandals. No bare feet.
* Wear long pants tucked into high socks, or duct tape around pant bottoms.
* Consider applying Deet for skin and permethrin for clothes (use your own best judgment in weighing exposure to these toxins against risk of tick bites).
* Wear white or light-colored clothing so ticks stand out.
* Check yourself and your children for ticks immediately after outdoor exposure. Repeat the tick check again, three days later. Remember that nymphal (adolescent) ticks can look like freckles. They are the size of poppy seeds.
* If you find an attached tick, remove it carefully with tweezers placed as close to the skin as possible. Pull the tick upward with steady, even pressure, making sure that mouth parts are cleanly removed. Apply antiseptic and call a doctor. Save the tick in a sealed container with a moist cotton ball. Call your state health department to inquire about testing. (Ticks do fall off on their own eventually, so even if you don’t see a tick, it is possible that you may have been exposed to disease.)
* Consult your doctor about treating the tick bite with oral antibiotics. Though the number of days required for this treatment remains controversial, new findings from CDC research suggest that the single dose of treatment generally recommended for this scenario may be inadequate and that a doxycycline sustained release protocol (19 days) the CDC is developing might be more effective.


Finding a Provider (Back to Top)
How to find a doctor to treat your tick-borne disease.

Lyme disease is never pleasant, but if you are exposed in endemic areas of the Northeast, the Midwest or the West Coast and develop the spreading red Lyme rash known as erythema migrans, the best person to consult is your family doctor. The classic Lyme disease rash is considered diagnostic for the disease in these areas, according to the standard guidelines from the Infectious Diseases Society of America (IDSA). Physicians following these widely accepted guidelines will not even have to order a blood test to make a bulletproof diagnosis. For most people without other complications, including other infections from the same tick bite, a month of treatment with oral antibiotics like doxycycline or amoxicillin should cure the disease.

Finding a doctor able to make the diagnosis and treat you adequately becomes far more challenging if you do not see or develop a rash, or if you live outside areas considered most endemic for the disease. Given the debate in the medical community over the classic signs and symptoms for Lyme, the inaccuracy of the tests, and the presence of complicating co-infections, patients in this circumstance can advance into later, harder-to-treat disease before they are ever diagnosed.

In this instance, it may be appropriate to consult a neurologist, rheumatologist or infectious disease doctor in your community for specialized but mainstream care. Following the IDSA guidelines, these physicians will treat these sicker patients with specialized antimicrobials aimed at co-infections, or with a month or two of intravenous Rocephin, which crosses the blood brain barrier and better penetrates the joints, often resolving Lyme disease.

But about 20 percent of patients diagnosed with late-stage Lyme disease report that they fail even this more aggressive treatment; others report that their co-infections are missed. Still sick, they find themselves navigating the tortuous backroads of the Lyme wars. Those seeking clinical evaluation of the range of tick-borne infections or continued treatment for Lyme disease itself — as I did with my own family — may decide to cross the line, leaving the restrictions of the mainstream viewpoint for the alternative world of Lyme doctors, referred to by patients as Lyme-Literate Medical Doctors, or LLMDs. These physicians will test patients for a range of co-infections and treat Lyme disease longer, using antibiotics in combination (as is done with tuberculosis cases) for months and sometimes years.

Many patients report recovery on such protocols — but many do not, and for them, the search for treatment goes on. Some patients consult trained naturopaths, who help them boost their immune systems. One new trend used by neurologists at New York University and Yale involves treatment with IVIG (intravenous immunoglobulin), a blood product rich in immune molecules that can heal damaged nerves.

For reference to a doctor skilled in mainstream protocols, contact the Infectious Diseases Society of America. For reference to a doctor willing to treat tick-borne infection beyond the standard guidelines, contact the Lyme Disease Association or the International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society. (See Web Resources, below.)

Web Resources (Back to Top)

* Infectious Diseases Society of America: www.idsociety.org
* Lyme Disease Association: www.lymediseaseassociation.org
* International Lyme and Associated Diseases Society: www.ilads.or




Enjoy the books you discover in each issue of Experience Life.
Amazon.com
LifeTime Fitness

Advertiser Services |Privacy Policy |Terms of Service |Contact Us

©2007 LIFE TIME FITNESS, Inc. All rights reserved. Life Time Fitness corporate headquarters: 2902 Corporate Place, Chanhassen, MN 55317 | Ph:952-947-0000

June 2009: Get Into Nature Subscribe

June 2009
Browse Contents
http://experiencelifemag.com/healthy-learning-resources/blue-zones.html
Behind the Scenes With Alexandra Coustea

Monday, March 30, 2009

A Must Read for Everyone !

Hello my friends,

I have borrowed this article from Michealene Cristini Risley. Her blog artice is absolutely a must read for everyone who might like to know about Lyme disease. Kudos to her for doing such a fine job in her article. I originally found it on this link:http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michealene-cristini-risley/lyme---emerging-disease-o_b_180728.html. I always give proper credit to articles I find and use on my blog. The object is to get as much quality information out there as possible. I hope you will take the time to read this article.
Be Well,
Richard
Michealene Cristini Risley
Posted March 30, 2009 | 11:47 AM (EST) BIO Become a Fan Get Email Alerts Bloggers' Index
Lyme - emerging disease or hidden epidemic?



Thomas Gray, the English poet once said, "Ignorance is truly bliss". "Bliss" is a wonderful form of denial if you are in the throes of disease, such as Lyme. The illness can be a painful and debilitating process, fraught with complicated treatments and medical ignorance. One can accept ignorance with an emerging disease, yet not from the organization that is responsible for setting guidelines for treatment such as the Infectious Diseases Society of America:
http://www.idsociety.org/.

One gets angrier when you begin to question the root of that ignorance in the national governing body. Is the behavior based on lack of knowledge or more subversive? Is there an ulterior motive to hide the truth of this ailment? The IDSA guidelines are used by health practitioners to treat the disorder and by many health insurance companies to make coverage decisions. This is the point where ignorance turns into systematic deception, when two parties attempt to squelch doctors who in their treatment have discovered that these guidelines in many cases do not work. These doctors have come under fire, in some cases losing their licenses for assisting people debilitated by this disease. There has been widespread anger by "lymies" (this is what we call ourselves) about controversial treatment options and inadequate guidelines. Still, nothing is being done, and people continue to get sick.

Last May, Connecticut Attorney General Richard Blumenthal announced that his antitrust investigation "uncovered serious flaws in the Infectious Disease Society of America's process for writing its 2006 Lyme disease guidelines..." "The IDSA guidelines have sweeping and significant impacts on Lyme disease medical care," Blumenthal wrote. "They are commonly applied by insurance companies in restricting coverage for long-term antibiotic treatment or other medical care and also strongly influence physician treatment decisions." http://www.ilads.org/press_2_07.htm

Several doctors in key roles on the panel were found to have conflicts of interest. "The IDSA's 2006 Lyme disease guideline panel undercut its credibility by allowing individuals with financial interests -- in drug companies, Lyme disease diagnostic tests, patents and consulting arrangements with insurance companies -- to exclude divergent medical evidence and opinion."

It is not just the IDSA, The Center for Disease Control http://www.cdc.gov/ncidod/dvbid/lyme/states the following: "Most cases of Lyme disease can be treated successfully with a few weeks of antibiotics." For those of us who have Lyme disease, a few weeks of antibiotics would not begin to attack the source of bacteria let alone the co-infections and dormant phases of the illness. Unfortunately, without proper treatment, the disease takes a stronger hold on the infected; making it much more difficult to cure.

For those of you who are lucky enough to not have any interaction with the disease or people infected, let me explain what Lyme disease is. Lyme disease is a bacterial infection caused by the bacteria Borrelia burgdorferi (Bb) that is commonly contracted from a deer tick bite. Researchers are also discovering that other insects such as; mosquitoes, fleas and lice may also transmit the disease.

Early Lyme disease can produce a wide-range of symptoms and is different in each person. In addition to the initial diagnosis, Lyme can carry many co-infections which can make a person much sicker. The treatment options are varied and most aggressive treatment forms are not supported by traditional western medicine. For now, those of us who have the disease are left on our own to find a treatment that works. It is terribly frightening.

A few years back I had spinal surgery-so I know what serious, debilitating pain is-and I would gladly opt for additional spine surgeries if I could get rid of Lyme disease. It is that debilitating.

Other transmission confirmations that the general public may not be aware of; Lyme disease can be transmitted in uterus, through breast milk and blood transfusions. Some Lyme specialist believes that the disease can be sexually transmitted since the bacteria can be found in saliva and semen; this form of transmission is still in question.

Another troubling aspect of the disease is ability to diagnosis the illness. In many parts of the United States, (and Lyme disease is everywhere) the diagnosis and testing are faulty. In the documentary "Under our Skin" http://www.underourskin.com many of the issues behind this disease are discussed. At one point, in the documentary, a series of "Lymies" show up on the screen. Each person states the number of doctors it took to get a proper diagnosis. Some were searching for years. My search for a diagnosis took five months and twenty-one doctors. Twenty-one doctors in the heart of Silicon Valley and in Stanford Hospitals' backyard. Before I got the diagnosis, I was told that I was pre-menopausal, iron deficient, that I had Addison's disease, Cushing's disease, Adrenal Fatigue and post-trauma from my imprisonment in Zimbabwe: http://www.huffingtonpost.com/michealene-cristini-risley/gratitude-musings-after-_b_62791.html

Other myths that need to be challenged include the statistics on the prevalence of Lyme disease. I contacted the CDC and talked to the San Mateo County Health Department, for the most part they were less than helpful. I was told by the San Mateo County Health Department that I am the only case of Rocky Mountain spotted fever, (another co-infection) in the state of California in over 15 years. I don't believe them. Other thoughts to convey to your physician:

• The number of cases, the geographical scope and the proportion of afflicted that are severe cases needs to be reviewed. Lyme disease is not decreasing, it in increasing. You can get Lyme disease during the winter.
• Over 50% of those people infected by Lyme disease do not get the distinguishing rash or Bull's eye.
• Over 50% of those with Lyme disease get a false-negative on the testing.

We do know that Lyme disease can be debilitating. The disease needs to be researched to figure out all transmission modes for this illness. Since testing for this disease is inadequate, more research needs to be done to determine better testing mechanisms. In my own experience and in reading books such as "Cure Unknown": http://www.cureunknown.com/ so many stories of doctors and facilities that do not believe that the disease exists.

Insurance companies have typically refused paying for treatments. I personally know that insurance companies are refusing many of my costs. This weekend, my insurance company, Blue Shield of California would only pay for 6 pills to rid me of parasites caused by the immune system fallout from Lyme. In order for me to get the proper prescription of the full 30 pills and to rid the parasite, I had to pay over two-thousand dollars for the additional 24 pills. I purchased enough for the weekend and will start to call Blue Shield on Monday. I wish I was kidding.

Many people who have Lyme disease have sounded the alarm, yet the medical establishment is not listening. Why are there so many disbelievers in Western medicine? Why are insurance companies denying the very basic of claims? If the IDSA guidelines are in question, shouldn't the insurance companies be reviewing what is covered?

Two weeks ago, I was so ill with Lyme, that I thought I was going to die. I was getting neurological symptoms, my right leg was caving in, and my mind would not work. I called the following hospitals; Stanford Hospital, Mayo Clinic, University of California-San Francisco, not a one of these top institutions would take me as a Lyme patient. I start to get an inkling what is must have been like at the beginning of the AIDS epidemic.

There are many issues facing our country right now. For me, Lyme disease is at the top of that list. Too many people are becoming debilitated from this disease, some are dying. It is time that the medical establishment takes the politics out of lyme and start practicing they oath they took to help the sick. You can make a difference. Get on-line, call your congress-person, call the White House at (202) 456-1414. Have a conversation with someone who has LYME disease. Help us to take action before Lyme's disease spreads further.

To each his sufferings: all are men,
Condemned alike to groan,
the tender for another's pain;
the unfeeling for his own.
Yet ah! Why should they know their fate?
Since sorrow never comes too late,
And happiness too swiftly flies.
Thought would destroy their paradise.
No more; where ignorance is bliss,
'Tis folly to be wise.

Friday, March 27, 2009

Lyme Disease and Rage

Hi my friends,
This is an interesting article concerning the current public discourse of Lyme Disease and whether it can cause incidents of rage.

I hope everyone is keeping up with the ISDA's current attempt to stop the treatment of Lyme disease with long-term antibiotics. I hope to post an update soon.

Be well,
Richard


Pastor killing: Another act of violence attributed to Lyme disease
March 9, 2009
From the Psychology Today blog, Emerging Diseases
By Pamela Weintraub

http://blogs.psychologytoday.com/blog/emerging-diseases/200903/pastor-killing-another-act-violence-attributed-lyme-disease
or http://tinyurl.com/ctxmlu

Here's a quick post to supplement my story on the chimp attack in
Connecticut, which some pundits attributed to a rage reaction caused by
Lyme disease.

On the heels of the rage-filled chimp story comes a human version: This
weekend a man opened fire on a pastor in a church in Maryville,
Illinois, murdering him with a rain of gunfire. Here, too, the
explanation for the attack has been given as psychiatric illness caused
by Lyme disease. Infected by a tick on the family farm in the early
1990's, the young man was, his family said, left with lesions on his brain.

There's no question that Lyme disease is a neurological illness. It has
been associated with neurological disease for decades in rigorous peer
review in the top medical journals in the world.

Read the complete blog post and join the conversation:
http://tinyurl.com/ctxmlu

Sunday, March 30, 2008

Lyme disease legislation, get involved.

Hello again friends,
I have inserted this excerpt from am e-mail I received from Lymeinfo.net. Here is a chance for all of us to be hard and help to get some worthwhile legislation passed. There is a sample letter included to make it easy for you to get involved. Believe me, your voice does make a difference.

Be well,
Richard


From Phyllis Mervine, California Lyme Disease Association:
Please use the phone/fax numbers below and get this letter, or a similar
one, off to as many of the subcommittee members as possible. Send a few
every day! Feel free to modify my letter.

Please let us know when you do anything so we can get some action going
among ourselves and inspire others to pitch in. This bill will not pass
without a massive effort - massive means small effort by MANY people,
rather than GREAT effort by a few. This is one time that NUMBERS MATTER.
Do your bit!
- Thank you Phyliss!

SAMPLE letter For You to Send to Support HR 741

Dear Congressman or Congresswoman __________:

I am writing to ask you to support HR 741, the Lyme and Tick-borne
Disease Prevention, Education, and Research Act of 2007. It is a
companion bill to S 1708

HR 741 recognizes Lyme disease as a serious and debilitating illness,
often misdiagnosed and under-reported. The CDC admits that only 10
percent of cases are reported. A Georgia study found that only one case
in FORTY is reported. In 2005, the CDC reported 23,305 cases. This means
that at least 233,050 cases occurred and probably more than 40 times
that many, or 932,200 cases. That does not count thousands of cases
never reported at all – cases misdiagnosed as MS, ALS, juvenile
rheumatoid arthritis, chronic fatigue, fibromyalgia, and many others,
and cases undiagnosed because of the insensitivity of the tests (which
miss almost half the cases). Tickborne diseases are costing this country
billions a year but most of the epidemic is hidden because of misdiagnosis.

People who are not diagnosed and treated properly become chronically ill
and are as disabled as people with congestive heart disease.

HR 741 establishes a Tick-Borne Diseases Advisory Committee and calls
for improvements in three broad categories – diagnostic tests,
surveillance; prevention – and for clinical outcomes research. The bill
authorizes an additional $100 million over five years to accomplish
these activities.

Please ask Chairman Pallone for a hearing on HR 741. Lyme disease is a
nationwide health problem that needs and deserves serious efforts to
contain it and prevent it. Over 90 Lyme disease patient groups support
this bill.

Sincerely yours,

- -

First # is phone, second is FAX. Call and speak to the health aide or
even better, fax a letter.

*Majority Members (Democrats)*

Frank Pallone, Jr. (D-NJ) [Chairman] 202-225-4671; 202-225-9665
Henry A. Waxman (D-CA) 202-225-3976; 202-225-4099
Edolphus Towns (D-NY) 202-225-5936; 202-225-1018
Bart Gordon (D-TN) 202-225-4231; 202-225-6887
Anna G. Eshoo (D-CA) 202-225-8104; 202-225-8890
Gene Green (D-TX) 202-225-1688; 202-225-9903
Diana DeGette (D-CO) 202-225-4431; 202-225-5657
Lois Capps (D-CA) 202-225-3601; 202-225-5632
Thomas H. Allen (D-ME) 202-225-6116; 202-225-5590
Tammy Baldwin (D-WI) 202-225-2906; 202-225-6942
Eliot L. Engel (D-NY) 202-225-2464; 202-225-5513
Janice Schakowsky (D-IL) 202-225-2111; 202-226-6890
Hilda A. Solis (D-CA) 202-225-5464; 202-225-5467
Michael A. Ross (D-AR) 202-225-3772; 202-225-1314
Darlene Hooley (D-OR) 202-225-5711; 202-225-5699
Anthony Weiner (D-NY) 202-225-6616; 202-226-7253
James D. Matheson (D-UT) 202-225-3011; 202-225-5638

*Minority Members (Republicans)*

Nathan Deal (R-GA) [Rankiing Member] 202-225-5211; 202-225-8272
Ralph M. Hall (R-TX) 202-225-6673; 202-225-3332
Barbara Cubin (R-WY) 202-225-2311; 202-225-3057
Heather A. Wilson (R-NM) 202-225-6316; 202-225-4975
John B. Shadegg (R-AZ) 202-225-3361; 202-225-3462
Stephen E. Buyer (R-IN) 202-225-5037; 202-225-2267
Joseph R. Pitts (R-PA) 202-225-2411; 202-225-2013
Mike Ferguson (R-NJ) 202-225-5361; 202-225-9460
Mike Rogers (R-MI) 202-225-4872; 202-225-5820
Sue Myrick (R-NC) 202-225-1976; 202-225-3389
John Sullivan (R-OK) 202-225-2211; 202-225-9187
Tim Murphy (R-PA) 202-225-2301; 202-225-1844
Michael Burgess (R-TX) 202-225-7772; 202-225-2919
Marsha Blackburn (R-TN) 202-225-2811; 202-225-3004


__._,_.___
The mission of LymeInfo is to keep you informed of issues that might be of interest to Lyme disease patients. Postings are not meant to imply that we agree with the content of all items we distribute.

For Lyme information, see:
http://www.LymeInfo.net

About Me

My photo
Pueblo, Colorado, United States
I am a Chronic Lyme disease patient. I was bitten by a tick in 2001 and have been very sick ever since. Subsequently, you could say I am a Lyme disease junkie.I thirst for any information about it,any treatments, research etc. It has been a life altering experience, which has kept me away from our business and at home most of the time. I use to own A-1 Barricade and Sign Inc. here in Pueblo, Co, but because of the Lyme disease, my sons are running the business for the most part with my wife. I have been married for 48 years to a wonderful woman who is also my best friend. We have five children, all grown. Four boys live here in Pueblo and my only daughter lives in Bonney Lake, Washington. We miss her a lot. I have 7 grandchildren, which are the greatest of all. They are all exceptionally beautiful! The last thing you need to know about me is that I am proud to be a member of The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-Day Saints. Because of this I have the knowledge that life is eternal and that it does not end here, but it will go on after death because of the Atonement of Jesus Christ. This truth I bear witness of!